Videos

Roth Conversion Series- Is a Roth Conversion Right for You?

When It Makes Sense and When It May Not | Gainline Financial Partners

Is a Roth Conversion Right for You? When It Makes Sense and When It May Not

Roth conversions get talked about a lot right now, and it’s easy to come away thinking everyone should do one. There’s no universal rule. A conversion can make a lot of sense in some situations and be a poor fit in others, so it helps to know which ones apply to you.

When a conversion is often worth a closer look

  1. A low-income year, or several. This is the most common situation. Think of someone who retired early and is in the gap before Social Security and required minimum distributions begin, someone taking a career break, or a business owner having a down year. Lower income can mean a lower tax cost to convert.
  2. Expecting higher income later. A large pre-tax balance in an IRA or 401(k) can lead to sizable required minimum distributions down the road. A pension that starts later can also raise your income. If your future income or tax rate may be higher, converting some money sooner may make sense.
  3. Paying the tax from outside the IRA. If you can cover the tax from regular savings or a brokerage account, the full converted amount stays invested in the Roth.
  4. More years in the Roth. The longer the money can stay in the Roth, the more time it has for tax-free growth, and the easier it is to satisfy the five-year rule. Conversions are generally more appropriate for younger people with a long time horizon, though that isn’t always the case.
  5. Heirs in a higher tax bracket. Children who inherit a traditional IRA generally have to empty it within 10 years, and those withdrawals add to their own taxable income. If your heirs are doctors, lawyers or in another high-earning career, they could be paying more on those distributions while you’re in a lower bracket. Paying the tax a little earlier may make sense.
  6. Married couples planning ahead. When one spouse passes away, the survivor usually starts filing single, which means narrower tax brackets. Converting while you still file jointly may be worth considering.

 

When a conversion may be less appealing

  1. Using IRA money to pay the tax. Less ends up in the Roth, and if you’re under 59½ you could face penalties.
  2. A high bracket now and a lower one later. If you expect to be in a lower tax bracket in retirement, converting today may cost more than it saves.
  3. Needing the money within about five years. Because of the five-year rule, if you’re under 59½ and take money out before that clock is up, you could face penalties.
  4. Being close to an income threshold. The extra income from a conversion could raise your Medicare premiums through IRMAA, reduce ACA subsidies or affect financial aid.
  5. Leaving pre-tax assets to charity. A qualified charity doesn’t pay income tax on an inherited IRA. Converting that money first means paying tax that no one would otherwise have paid.
  6. Moving to a lower-tax state. If you plan to move from a high-tax state such as California to one with lower or no income tax, such as Florida, waiting may make more sense.
  7. Planning qualified charitable distributions. QCDs come directly from an IRA once you reach an eligible age. Keeping those dollars pre-tax means neither you nor the charity pays tax on them.

 

It doesn’t have to be all or nothing

Conversions tend to make the most sense when today’s tax cost is low compared with what those same dollars might cost later. You also don’t have to convert everything at once. Partial conversions spread over several years are an option, and it’s a strategy we use with many of our clients at Gainline.

Your next step

Every situation is different, so the best next step is to run projections with a qualified tax professional or your financial advisor before making any decision. 

This video wraps up our Roth Conversion Series. If you missed the earlier parts, Part 1 covers what a Roth conversion is, and Part 2 covers why some people choose to pay the taxes early.

Disclosure:
Investment advisory services offered through Gainline Financial Partner, LLC a Registered Investment Advisor with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. This material is intended for informational purposes only. It should not be construed as legal or tax advice and is not intended to replace the advice of a qualified attorney or tax advisor. The information contained may have been compiled from third-party sources and is believed to be reliable.